danger/u/
This thread is permanently archived
Kirito Kamui or Makishima Shougo?

| Who is a better antagonist it protagonist (whichever you prefer to call them).

Btw they are from the anime "Psycho Pass"

~Noblige~


| Makishima's special ability can be linked to human psychology, while kamui's is just.... an asspull. Really, 1 person survived the accident and made of all the victim? What will we have next, a furry that obsesses with animals and merged themselves with a whole zoo? I think there's a long vid in youtube that explains why kamui isn't as good as makishima anyways.


| Kamui is boring, bland and his backstory makes no fucking sense. Makishima is intense, intimidating and has actual screen presence. It's not really a fair comparison.


| Makishima is a villain that ull love unlike the other guy whos just plain boring


| I agree that the backstory of Kamui was a farfetch, still I kinda liked how he forces Sibyl to judge itself as a group.Makishima was awesome as well! Anyways thanks guys!

~Noblige~


| Except that... we learned in season 1 that the system is made of people with perma low psychopass like makishima. So if the brains have low score, how can the system as a whole has a high score?


| Hmm good point,but I think the system is judged in their own judgements. And the Perma low psychopaths thing.. in the end of season 2 they asked Akane to join them as well. Although her psycho pass can get clouded. So this somehow contradicts the fact that only people with permanently low psychopass get to join the system. This leads to my assumption that people with permanently low psychopass as well as people with high tolerance get into the program.


| Or rather wait... I am wrong about the above one. In season 2 they say that "even though all the individuals of a group may have low psychopass,but the group as collectively can have high psychopass and will be judged on that accordingly". That answers your question


| But if such thing occurs what will the system do? Eliminate a high psychopass group of (for example) politicians that individually do nothing wrong, but collectively bad for the system or let them live?


| How will the system determine wether to prioritize individual psychopass or the group psychopass?


| That's what the concern was if you remember the ending of season 2. Sibyl itself said that it might lead to massacres. Mass killings might come into play. That hasn't been explained yet or if it has them I missed it. Maybe the manga has some answers.

~Noblige~

Total number of posts: 11, last modified on: Sun Jan 1 00:00:00 1512713099

This thread is permanently archived